Is Your Target’s EBITDA Real or Not?

What is a Quality of Earnings Report?

Think of a QofE report as the financial world's version of a home inspection. While standard audits focus on compliance, QofE reports are investment-focused, drilling deep into whether a company's earnings are real, sustainable, and repeatable.

This isn't about catching fraud – it's about understanding the quality of profits you're buying. Are those impressive margins from sustainable advantages, or did the seller defer maintenance to inflate results? Is revenue growth market-driven, or did they stuff the sales channel?

Key focus areas include:

• Revenue recognition practices

• One-time vs. recurring items

• Working capital adjustments

• Expense normalization

• EBITDA add-backs validation

It's the lender's "trust but verify" mechanism, providing independent assessment of whether the seller's financial picture reflects economic reality.

Why Non-SBA Lenders Demand QofE Reports

The difference between SBA and non-SBA acquisition financing comes down to risk. SBA deals involve asset-backed lending with government guarantees. Non-SBA lenders like BDCs, SBICs, and private credit funds make cash-flow dependent loans with limited collateral coverage.

When you're lending $10 million against future cash flows rather than hard assets, earnings quality becomes everything.

Common red flags QofE uncovers:

• Channel stuffing to boost quarterly results

• Deferred expenses inflating margins

• Related party transactions inflating revenue

• Aggressive revenue recognition

The QofE serves as the lender's early warning system. If they're betting millions on earnings, they need independent verification those earnings are real and sustainable.

What QofE Reports Reveal

A comprehensive QofE report examines six critical areas:

Revenue Analysis

• Customer concentration risks: Is 40% of revenue from one customer?

• Revenue sustainability: Organic growth vs. one-time gains

• Seasonality patterns: Working capital and cash flow timing

• Contract analysis: Recurring revenue validation

Expense Normalization

• Owner compensation adjustments: Minimal salary but loaded perks

• One-time expenses: Was that $200K "consulting fee" really non-recurring?

• Related party transactions: Arm's length pricing verification

• Discretionary expenses: Which costs are truly optional?

Working Capital Assessment

• Cash conversion cycles: Time to convert investments to cash

• Seasonal working capital needs: Cash required for growth/fluctuations

• Receivables and inventory quality: Actually collectible and worth book value?

EBITDA Add-backs Validation

The most contentious area. Sellers present adjusted EBITDA adding back "non-recurring" expenses. QofE scrutinizes each adjustment:

• Professional fees and transaction costs

• Management departure costs

• Facility closure expenses

This often reveals seller's adjusted EBITDA is significantly higher than independent analysis supports.

Financial Controls and Systems

• Accounting system reliability

• Internal controls effectiveness

• Management reporting quality

• IT system dependencies

Market Position and Competitive Dynamics

• Industry outlook and competitive positioning

• Customer relationship strength

• Competitive advantages sustainability

• Management team capabilities

Cost Analysis: Big Firm vs. Boutique

QofE reports cost $15,000 to $100,000+ depending on firm selection and deal complexity.

Big Four/Major Firms ($50K-$100K+)

• Comprehensive scope and extensive resources

• Deep industry databases

• Strong lender credibility

• Established financing relationships

Mid-Tier Firms ($25K-$45K)

• Balanced approach with solid capabilities

• Industry specialization options

• Reasonable turnaround times

• Good lender acceptance

Boutique Specialists ($10K-$30K)

• Focused sector expertise

• Faster turnaround potential

• Most cost-effective option

• May require lender education

Cost factors: Deal complexity, timeline, geographic scope, industry risks, data quality

The Lender's Lens: How QofE Impacts Your Deal

Lenders use QofE findings for virtually every underwriting decision aspect.

Loan structure and terms:

• Clean results = higher leverage ratios, favorable coverage requirements

• Earnings concerns = lower loan amounts, higher equity requirements

• Personal guarantees correlate with sustainability questions

Interest rates and fees:

• Strong earnings = lower pricing

• Identified risks = higher rates and fees

Common deal-killers:

• Deteriorating customer base

• Unsustainable EBITDA margins

• Management departure risks

• Adverse market conditions

Negotiation leverage: Clean QofE results strengthen buyer position with lenders. Negative findings shift leverage to lenders demanding additional protections.

Strategic Timing and Process Management

Successful acquirers commission QofE reports immediately after gaining data room access, allowing 3-4 weeks for completion. This timing permits using findings in purchase price negotiations while meeting lender requirements.

Critical coordination elements:

• Complement legal and operational due diligence

• Negotiate data room access upfront

• Ensure management availability for interviews

• Share findings across all advisors

Your Quality of Earnings Roadmap

In sophisticated acquisition financing, Quality of Earnings reports aren't optional – they're your credibility certificate. Every serious lender financing cash-flow dependent deals requires independent earnings verification.

Your action plan:

• Budget for QofE costs early

• Select appropriate firm for your deal size

• Coordinate timing with lender requirements

• Use findings to strengthen negotiation position

The upfront investment typically pays for itself through improved loan terms, reduced lender requirements, and protection against overpaying for unsustainable earnings.

Remember: in acquisition financing, Quality of Earnings isn't just a report – it's the foundation of your entire financing strategy. This investment can mean the difference between closing your dream acquisition and watching it slip away.

Tell a Friend

If you received this newsletter from a friend, don't miss out on future insights. Subscribe now at thefinancingflow.net to receive weekly issues directly to your inbox.

To your financing success!